Tags: all welcome, lobby, player count, matchmaking, beyond all reason
All-welcome lobbies in Beyond All Reason have a practical ceiling around 15 opponents. Past that point, game performance and coordination break down.
All-welcome lobbies accept anyone who clicks join, which makes them the easiest entry point for new players. When the host count climbs past 15 opponents, several things degrade at once. Match start times stretch to unreasonable lengths. Pathfinding units lag as the engine tracks hundreds of entities. Team coordination falls apart simply because there are too many channels of communication to manage. The host running the lobby will typically see performance issues first, since their machine coordinates the initial handshake for every joining player.
If you join a full all-welcome lobby, expect a wait while the game simulates lobby state synchronization. Once the match loads, the map will feel crowded. Unit production chains slow down because shared metal spots become contested before the first commander even finishes its initial build queue. Team chat turns into a jumble of overlapping orders.
For a cleaner first experience, look for smaller lobbies in the 4 to 8 player range. The game actually teaches you more in that environment because you get to see cause-and-effect clearly without the noise of a massive skirmish.
Occasional massive games are fun for the novelty. A 16-plus game on a large map with scattered teammates creates a chaotic, free-for-all feel that some players enjoy after the holidays or as a weekend activity. Treat it as a party game, not a practice session. You will learn more about BAR from focused smaller matches than from the visual noise of a huge lobby.
All-welcome lobbies are a great idea that works best at moderate sizes. Jump in for the energy, but drop into smaller games when you actually want to improve. Communities like Creed of Champions run structured matches where the team size is tuned for learning and coordinated play without the overhead of a bloated lobby.
[Crd] One of the few places where you can for sure coordinate with people in matches with a good supportive attitude. Everybody tends to be understanding and constructive.